Black Holes

The Ultimate Enigma: Regions of spacetime where gravity is so strong that nothing, not even light, can escape.

Reissner-Nordström Black Holes

The Reissner-Nordström solution describes spherically symmetric, charged, non-rotating black holes. Although astrophysical black holes are nearly neutral, this solution reveals crucial theoretical insights including multiple horizons, extremal limits, and connections to cosmic censorship.

The Charged Black Hole Solution

The Reissner-Nordström metric, independently discovered by Hans Reissner (1916) and Gunnar Nordström (1918), generalizes the Schwarzschild solution to include electric charge. It is an exact solution to the coupled Einstein-Maxwell equations.

While astrophysical black holes are expected to be nearly electrically neutral (any net charge would be quickly neutralized by accreting plasma), the Reissner-Nordström solution is theoretically important for understanding:

  • The structure of spacetime with electromagnetic energy
  • Extremal black holes and their thermodynamic properties
  • Cosmic censorship conjecture
  • Connection to magnetically charged black holes (electromagnetic duality)
  • Analogy to rotating (Kerr) black holes

Reissner-Nordström Metric

The line element in Schwarzschild-like coordinates is:

$$ds^2 = -f(r)c^2dt^2 + f(r)^{-1}dr^2 + r^2d\Omega^2$$

where the metric function includes both gravitational and electromagnetic contributions:

$$f(r) = 1 - \frac{2GM}{c^2r} + \frac{GQ^2}{c^4r^2} = 1 - \frac{r_s}{r} + \frac{r_Q^2}{r^2}$$

The characteristic length scales are:

  • Schwarzschild radius: $r_s = 2GM/c^2$
  • Charge radius: $r_Q = \sqrt{GQ^2/c^4} = Q\sqrt{G/c^4}$

⚡ Electromagnetic Field

The electric field is purely radial:

$$\mathbf{E} = \frac{Q}{r^2}\hat{r}, \quad E^2 = \frac{Q^2}{r^4}$$

The electromagnetic stress-energy tensor contributes to spacetime curvature, modifying the metric from Schwarzschild.

Horizons and Singularity Structure

The horizons occur where $f(r) = 0$:

$$r_\pm = \frac{r_s}{2} \pm \sqrt{\left(\frac{r_s}{2}\right)^2 - r_Q^2} = \frac{GM}{c^2} \pm \sqrt{\frac{G^2M^2}{c^4} - \frac{GQ^2}{c^4}}$$

Three distinct cases arise:

Sub-extremal

$Q^2 < GM^2$ (or $r_Q < r_s/2$)

Two distinct horizons exist:

  • Outer horizon $r_+$ (event horizon)
  • Inner horizon $r_-$ (Cauchy horizon)

Similar to Schwarzschild, but with an inner horizon hiding the singularity.

Extremal

$Q^2 = GM^2$ (or $r_Q = r_s/2$)

The two horizons coincide:

$$r_+ = r_- = \frac{GM}{c^2} = r_Q$$

A single degenerate horizon. Zero temperature in thermodynamic sense. Maximum charge for given mass.

Super-extremal

$Q^2 > GM^2$ (or $r_Q > r_s/2$)

No real horizons exist. The singularity at $r=0$ is naked (visible to external observers).

⚠️ Violates cosmic censorship conjecture!

Believed not to form from physically reasonable initial conditions.

🔍 Physical Interpretation

  • Outer horizon $r_+$: Event horizon—causal boundary, one-way membrane
  • Inner horizon $r_-$: Cauchy horizon—boundary of predictability, classically unstable to perturbations
  • Singularity at r = 0: Timelike singularity (unlike Schwarzschild's spacelike one)
  • Region between $r_-$ and $r_+$ is causally disconnected from both infinity and the singularity

Surface Gravity and Hawking Temperature

The surface gravity at the outer horizon is:

$$\kappa = \frac{c^4(r_+ - r_-)}{4Gr_+^2} = \frac{c^4}{4GM}\cdot\frac{\sqrt{M^2 - Q^2/G}}{M^2 + \sqrt{M^4 - M^2Q^2/G}}$$

The Hawking temperature is:

$$T_H = \frac{\hbar\kappa}{2\pi k_Bc} = \frac{\hbar c^3}{8\pi GMk_B}\cdot\frac{\sqrt{M^2 - Q^2/G}}{M^2 + \sqrt{M^4 - M^2Q^2/G}}$$

Limiting Cases

  • Schwarzschild limit ($Q \to 0$): Recovers $T_H = \hbar c^3/(8\pi GMk_B)$
  • Extremal limit ($Q \to \sqrt{G}M$): $\kappa \to 0$, $T_H \to 0$
  • Charge reduces temperature: $T_H(Q) < T_H(0)$

Entropy

Bekenstein-Hawking entropy of outer horizon:

$$S = \frac{k_BA_+}{4\ell_P^2} = \frac{\pi k_Bc r_+^2}{\hbar G}$$

where $A_+ = 4\pi r_+^2$ is the area of the outer horizon.

🌡️ Thermodynamic Properties

Extremal Reissner-Nordström black holes ($T = 0$) are thermodynamically special:

  • Zero temperature but finite entropy ($S = \pi k_BGM^2/\hbar c$)
  • Third law violation: cannot reach $T = 0$ in finite steps
  • Maximum efficiency for charged black hole engines
  • Important role in supersymmetric theories and string theory

Causal Structure and Penrose Diagrams

The Reissner-Nordström spacetime has a rich causal structure revealed by Penrose diagrams:

Maximal Extension

Like Schwarzschild, the Reissner-Nordström solution can be maximally extended, but with crucial differences:

  • Infinite series of asymptotically flat regions connected through wormholes
  • Inner horizon $r_-$ separates black hole interior from a new region
  • Timelike singularity at $r=0$ can be avoided (unlike Schwarzschild)
  • Theoretical possibility of traversing to other universes

⚠️ Classical Instability

The inner horizon is classically unstable:

  • Mass inflation: Perturbations from early universe cause exponential growth of energy density near $r_-$
  • Cauchy horizon instability: $r_-$ is not a true event horizon; predictability breaks down
  • Realistic black holes likely have $r_-$ replaced by a spacelike singularity
  • Strong cosmic censorship conjecture: generic black holes have no Cauchy horizon

Cosmic Censorship Conjecture

Reissner-Nordström solutions are central to discussions of cosmic censorship:

Weak Cosmic Censorship

"Singularities arising from gravitational collapse are always hidden behind event horizons."

  • Forbids naked singularities (super-extremal case)
  • Protects external observers from singularity pathologies
  • Conjectured but not rigorously proven
  • Violations would allow time travel paradoxes

Strong Cosmic Censorship

"Generic spacetimes are globally hyperbolic (no Cauchy horizons)."

  • Inner horizon $r_-$ should not persist in realistic situations
  • Quantum effects or perturbations destroy $r_-$
  • Preserves determinism of general relativity
  • More controversial than weak censorship

Astrophysical Relevance

Why study charged black holes if astrophysical black holes are neutral?

Theoretical Importance

  • Analogy to Kerr: $Q$ in RN is analogous to $J$ in Kerr—both introduce second parameter
  • Extremal limits: Extremal RN helps understand extremal Kerr (rapidly spinning black holes)
  • Supersymmetry: Extremal charged black holes preserve some supersymmetry in SUGRA/string theory
  • AdS/CFT: RN black holes in Anti-de Sitter space model strongly coupled field theories
  • Hawking radiation: Charge affects evaporation dynamics and final state

🔋 Why Astrophysical Black Holes Are Neutral

Any net charge is rapidly neutralized:

  • Surrounding plasma contains both electrons and ions
  • Oppositely charged particles preferentially accrete
  • Timescale for neutralization: microseconds to seconds
  • Upper limits: $|Q|/M \lesssim 10^{-18}$ for stellar-mass BHs
  • Magnetic fields (not charge) dominate electromagnetic effects in astrophysics

Summary

Key Takeaways

  • • Reissner-Nordström metric: Spherically symmetric solution with electric charge $Q$
  • • Two horizons: Outer event horizon $r_+$ and inner Cauchy horizon $r_-$ (sub-extremal case)
  • • Extremal limit: $Q = \sqrt{G}M$ gives $T = 0$ with single degenerate horizon
  • • Super-extremal: $Q > \sqrt{G}M$ produces naked singularity, violating weak cosmic censorship
  • • Timelike singularity: Unlike Schwarzschild, the $r=0$ singularity can theoretically be avoided
  • • Classical instabilities: Inner horizon subject to mass inflation; likely unstable in realistic scenarios
  • • Thermodynamics: Temperature decreases with charge; extremal BHs have zero temperature but finite entropy
  • • Astrophysically rare: Real black holes are nearly neutral due to plasma neutralization
  • • Theoretical laboratory: Essential for understanding extremal limits, supersymmetry, and quantum gravity

Navigation

← Previous
Penrose Process
↑ Up
Part II Overview
Next →
Kerr-Newman Solution